Are You Using Misconduct Data to Prevent Problems?

Workplace bullying and harassment have climbed steadily up the agenda in recent years, with regulation starting to catch up. But new research suggests that most UK employers still have work to do before their reporting processes actually translate into prevention.

Collecting misconduct data is only half the job

Does your organisation has a way for people to raise concerns? A speak-up line, an HR inbox, an anonymous form? If so, you’ve already done something a lot of employers still haven’t. But new research suggests that having the reports isn’t the same as learning from them.

A survey of 300 senior HR professionals, carried out by workplace culture platform Culture Shift for its Culture Shifters Report 26/27, found that only 41% of organisations consistently pull together and analyse their misconduct or speak-up data to spot patterns. Another 41% only do this now and then, and 18% either don’t look for patterns at all or aren’t sure if anyone does.

The gap gets even wider when it comes to acting on what’s found. Just 43% of HR professionals said they regularly use insights from reporting data to shape preventative action. 42% do this occasionally, and 15% rarely or never do. In practice, that means a lot of valuable information is sitting in inboxes and spreadsheets, telling a story nobody’s reading.

The gap between perception and reality

Here’s where it gets uncomfortable. 91% of HR professionals believe their employees feel safe to report misconduct. But when Culture Shift asked employees directly, a very different picture emerged: 57% of those who’d experienced bullying or harassment in the past year chose not to report it, with many saying it simply wasn’t worth the personal risk.

The confidence gap is even wider by seniority. Junior employees are twice as likely as senior leaders to believe that speaking up is pointless because nothing meaningful will change (54% vs 27%). If your organisation’s misconduct data only reflects what people feel safe enough to report, it may be telling you far less than you think.

Why this matters more from October

This isn’t just a “nice to have” any more. Under the Employment Rights Act 2025, employers of every size are expected to face a strengthened duty from October 2026. This requires them to show they’ve taken all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment at work, up from the current standard of “reasonable steps.” That means being able to demonstrate genuine prevention, not just pointing to the fact that a reporting process exists.

If misconduct reports are only ever handled one at a time, in isolation, it’s easy to miss the bigger picture. A pattern of behaviour from one person, a cluster of concerns from one team, or a series of low-level issues that, left unchecked, could escalate into something more serious.

It’s also worth checking your confidence against your evidence. 91% of HR leaders say they could evidence compliance if challenged today. Sounds promising, right? In reality, only half have clear reporting processes in place, fewer than four in ten regularly share reporting data with the board, and just 38% have completed a comprehensive risk assessment. Confidence and audit-ready evidence aren’t always the same thing.

From reactive to proactive

The research also flagged how misconduct data is actually managed day to day, and it’s a mixed picture. Many organisations are still relying on manual methods like spreadsheets or Word documents to track reports, rather than a dedicated system that makes it easy to spot trends over time. For smaller HR teams without specialist tools, this is understandable, but it does raise the question of whether a repeated concern about the same manager or team would actually be noticed.

As Culture Shift’s co-founder and CEO, Gemma McCall, put it, collecting data is only the starting point: real change comes from looking at reports collectively rather than case by case. Treating every report as a data point rather than just a problem to close out is what separates organisations that prevent issues from those that simply respond to them once they’ve already happened.

misconduct data

What SMEs can do now

You don’t need an enterprise-grade platform to start closing this gap. A few practical steps:

  • Set a regular review cadence. Even a quarterly look through your misconduct and speak-up records, however basic the format, is a big step up from never reviewing at all.
  • Look for repeats, not just individual cases. Same team, same manager, same type of issue- patterns are where the real risk usually hides.
  • Centralise what you can. If you’re relying on scattered spreadsheets or email threads, even a shared, structured log makes trends far easier to spot.
  • Link findings to action. A review is only useful if it feeds into training, policy updates, or management conversations, not just a filing exercise.
  • Check whether people actually feel safe to report. Low report numbers can mean a healthy workplace, or they can mean people don’t trust the process. Anonymous pulse surveys can help you tell the difference.
  • Document your prevention efforts. With the strengthened duty expected from October 2026, keeping a clear record of the steps you’ve taken will matter, not just the reports you’ve received.

Need help reviewing your procedures?

Misconduct data isn’t just a compliance record, it’s an early warning system. The organisations that get ahead of workplace issues are the ones who start reading it that way. We can help review and refine your procedures so you can breathe easy in October.

Contact us here, or email: hrhelp@hrpartner.co.uk

Lisa & the HR Partner Team